Skip to content
Marc & Structures
Index

Save your progress

Enter your email and we will send a secure sign-in link. There is no password and the first link creates your account.

Mission ~7 min · ~55 min remaining

Prediction and idealization

Anticipate why SOLID185 is suitable for teaching and what the section choice implies.

Before you code — Predict

Suppose you run these instructions after meshing the entire beam with material 1:

MAT,2
ALLSEL,ALL

Do existing elements become aluminium? No. MAT,2 changes the material that subsequent elements will receive. It does not rewrite existing elements. This distinction will be the common thread of the lesson.

Physical Model — Choosing Idealization

The same part can be represented by an axis, a midsurface, or its volume. Each reduction retains some information and discards other information. The most complex element is not automatically the most correct: the appropriate idealization is the simplest that answers reliably to the engineering question.

Comparison of BEAM188, SHELL181 and SOLID185 idealizations
The input geometry changes with the idealization: line, midsurface, or volume.
ElementRepresentingNodal Degrees of FreedomSection
BEAM188Line 3D3 translations + 3 rotations; optional warpIt is defined with section commands.
SHELL181Midsurface3 translations + 3 rotationsThickness and layers defined through a section.
SOLID185Volume 3D3 translationsThe shape of the volume provides the section.

Why we use SOLID185

SOLID185 is a solid structural element of eight nodes and three displacements per node. We chose it because the running example will later need faces to apply pressures, inspect local fields, and model possible interfaces. It also keeps visible the relationship between volume, elements and nodes that you learned in M02.

A didactic decision is not a universal rule

For the overall displacement of a slender beam, BEAM188 can be more efficient and appropriate. A solid 3D demands proper resolution of its mesh and boundary conditions. M04 will study that responsibility.

Sections: When they appear

A line or surface alone does not contain all the transverse geometry:

! Conceptual beam example
ET,2,BEAM188
SECTYPE,1,BEAM,RECT
SECDATA,beam_b,beam_h
TYPE,2
SECNUM,1

! Conceptual shell example
ET,3,SHELL181
SECTYPE,2,SHELL
SECDATA,thickness
TYPE,3
SECNUM,2

SECTYPE starts the definition, SECDATA provides their data and SECNUM activates the number for subsequent elements. In our BLOCK, width and height are already part of the volume; adding an additional section for SOLID185 does not add physical information.